Guiding Principles:
Making Smart Investments with Stimulus Funding
With the passing of multiple relief bills, large amounts of
federal and state money have been infused into local governments to
combat the lingering economic effects of COVID-19 shutdowns.
It is
incumbent upon governments to approach this rare moment responsibly,
with an eye toward strategic long-term sustainability. Smart investments
can make transformative progress and ensure that
structural gaps are narrowed and closed in our budgets and our
communities.
There are several ways in which local governments can make smart
decisions to improve municipal finances. An economic recovery that helps
people will lead to a more sustainable
recovery for our County government's finances as well.
It appears that Nassau County will be ending fiscal year 2020
with a surplus rather than a deficit. This is largely due to the infusion of federal CARES Act dollars, proactive
measures taken by the County related to debt service costs, and a lower than expected impact scenario on sales tax.
The Comptroller’s
Office is responsible for preparing and issuing the County’s financial
statements and is currently working on the 2020 annual financial report, which is expected to be issued by June 30, 2021. The 2020 report will provide
details on how Nassau County finished the year, and provide the County’s official
audited fiscal year results.
American Rescue Plan Act
With the signing of The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (“ARPA”) into law (1), Nassau County is expected
to receive an infusion of $385 million from the $1.9 trillion package.
ARPA funds will be issued in two tranches to local
governments to be used in the 2021 and 2022 budgets. All funds must be spent by the end of calendar year
2024.
The United States Treasury Department has issued an Interim Final Rule with guidance for using ARPA funds, while seeking comments on this guidance until mid-July 2021. The report will detail ways that Nassau County can apply these funds responsibly, with an eye toward strategic long-term sustainability.
Smart investments can make transformative progress and ensure that structural gaps are narrowed and closed in our budgets and our communities.
Let's Get Local: Making Smart Decisions in Nassau County
The Government Finance Officers Association asserts that the
funding provided under ARPA provides a unique opportunity for state
and local governments to make strategic investments in long-lived
assets, rebuild reserves to enhance financial stability and cover
temporary operating shortfalls until economic conditions and operations
normalize.
While the
$350 billion heading to state and local governments is an incredible
opportunity
for not only relief but growth, governments may fall into budgetary traps if
they make the wrong decisions with the non-recurring funds. Care should be taken to avoid creating new programs or
add-ons to existing programs that require an ongoing financial commitment.
We have illustrated in past Policy and Research reports that Nassau County’s long-term financial success relies upon ensuring that there are opportunities for all.
By embracing innovative and proactive solutions, we can help ensure Nassau County’s long-term financial
success by making smart
decisions to improve municipal finances, help people make a real difference and also lead to a more
sustainable economy.
Small Business Majority, an advocacy organization focused on supporting small businesses, has supported policies including rent
relief programs, unrestricted
grant assistance (prioritizing the smallest of businesses, such as those with 20 employees or less), funding
for greater technical assistance to small businesses, and a moratorium
on some licensing and permitting costs. Many other organizations have also advocated for common-sense solutions we can capitalize on to seize the moment.
How Nassau County Can Make Smart Investments
- Invest Money to Reduce Operating Costs
- Make Overdue Investments in Technology Infrastructure
- Make Investments in Our Residents
1. Invest Money to Reduce Operating Costs
We've illustrated in the first volume of our What's the Issue Series about infrastructure how Nassau's deferred infrastructure investments will only cost the County in the long-run. Now is an opportunity to make long-overdue investments in
infrastructure. Smart projects that wouldn’t have been possible before - but are now possible due to stimulus money - can drive economic growth, allowing
the County to get a return on investment on these dollars and ultimately putting Nassau County on the path to long-term sustainability.
Making Infrastructure Investments
On Long Island, our infrastructure challenges require improvements
and investments in projects that can provide additional capacity
to heavily traveled transportation corridors and vitalize the efficiency
of the region’s transportation system. The COVID-19 pandemic has
created an urgency to invest in much-needed infrastructure. The
uncertain access to financial markets and the lack of borrowing in 2020
have constrained Nassau County's 2021-2024 Capital Plan (2). Large-scale infrastructure improvements were re-sequenced to late 2021 with
the expectation of reduced funding.
Twelve Priority Projects
Recently, Nassau County Executive Laura Curran joined with labor leaders to call for a $583 million federal infrastructure stimulus to advance twelve priority projects. Funding these projects with stimulus money would create (3):
Jump-start Development
The Long Island
Regional Planning Council has predicted that substantial regional land
uses will likely be altered significantly in its recent "Land-Use
Impacts Post COVID-19" study. Increased demand for multi-generational
housing and “pop-up” retail in downtowns with significant vacancies are
among the study’s key predictions, along with the need for updated
zoning laws reflecting work-from-home needs (4).
In the four decades between 1970 to 2010, the number of people on Long Island
that live alone increased by 65%, while the number of married families
with children decreased by 28% (5). These shifts have created more
demand for centrally-located housing units geared toward single people
and non-married couples. A 2016 Long Island Index survey
found that 15% of Long Islanders either live in an apartment, condo, or
townhouse and 29% want to live in one of those options within five
years (6).
This
demand for alternative housing options, namely rental units, far
outpaces the supply. A 2013 Long Island’s Rental Housing Crisis report
found that 64% of renters cannot afford a typical two-bedroom apartment,
and that much of the cause is attributable to how little multi-family
housing has been built in Nassau and Suffolk Counties (7).
To read more about how Nassau's ever-increasing amounts of vacant underutilized
land include obsolete or decommissioned sumps and vacant strip malls can be re-imagined to meet the housing needs of the future, please check out our Local Economic Acceleration Series and Modernizing "The Deal" of Living in Nassau County.
2. Make Overdue Investments in Technology Infrastructure
During the pandemic, governments began to invest in technology like video conferencing to keep public meetings accessible, and with governments conducting more business online, there has been an
increased concern about cyber-threats.
Leveraging this unique opportunity with both short-term priorities and long-term needs in mind, Nassau County should make overdue investments in technology and cybersecurity and save unnecessary pain in the future.
Enterprise Resource Planning
For decades, Nassau County has used a now-obsolete computer system to
manage more than $3 billion annually in County spending, including the
payroll for 14,000 employees of the County and Nassau Community College.
This system, based on computer coding from 1992 and no longer
supported, wastes staff time creates inefficiencies, and would severely
hamper the ability for the County to operate in the event that the
system fails.
Nassau County’s current financial
system cannot efficiently produce GAAP-compliant
financial statements. A past
report issued by the County’s independent external
auditor described the issues with this system and classified them as a
“material weakness” in the
County’s internal control over financial reporting. The implementation
of an adequate accounting and reporting system will provide many
benefits to the
County.
Over the first three years, the Comptroller's Office
made successful advances toward replacing the County's legacy
mainframe-based financial system and implementing a new Human Resource
application. To read more about this process, please read our Three Years in Review highlight
3. Make Investments in Our Residents
Nassau County should explore using some of the money on social services and small
businesses in a way that helps address short-term needs, while leveraging this unprecedented infusion of
cash to make an equally unprecedented commitment to equity.
Relief for the Middle Class
Nassau County Executive Laura Curran has proposed sending
direct cash payments of $375 to some 300,000 County property owners,
using $100 million in pandemic aid from the federal government (8).
The County would use funding from the American Rescue Plan Act to send out individual
payments to property owners who receive the STAR or enhanced STAR exemptions, which are generally households earning
up to $500,000 and $88,050 or less respectively.
Increase Access to Child Care
New York State ranks 6th in the nation as having the most expensive
infant care. Child care for an infant costs $7,930 (112%) more per year
than in-state tuition for a four-year public college (9), which makes
New York one of 33 states where infant care costs more than public
college tuition.
Child care is a critical factor that
propels or stalls economic development. Parents that have access to
reliable child care are able to be more productive and miss less time at
work, which can help foster opportunities for upward mobility. In
simple terms, access to affordable child care allows more family members
the opportunity to earn more income and also helps close the gender
wage gap.
With COVID-19
exacerbating this challenge, and even shedding light on how dependent many
families already were on our education system to effectively serve as child care,
our report The Child Care Gap: How the Price of Child Care Impacts "The Deal" of Living in Nassau County takes a critical look at the issue.
Recent Developments
The New York State FY 2022 Budget includes a historic $5 billion investment
in child care through both state and federally funded initiatives
designed to restart our economy, support essential workers and child
care providers, and improve access to quality, affordable child care for
all eligible working New York families (10).
Help Small Businesses
In another effort to provide a major boost to
businesses as they continue to struggle with the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, Nassau County Executive Laura Curran proposed a major business
recovery program to direct approximately $25 million in American
Recovery Plan (ARPA) funds to grants, loans and assistance to Nassau’s
downtown businesses (11).
Advance Equity
The major healthcare inequities unmasked by COVID-19 and the
continued disparate treatment of people of color in America make it
clear that now more than ever is the right time to address major
inequality issues within our society.
Our
Office’s Equity Gap Toolkit report highlights data
demonstrating that there are clear equity gaps that must be closed. In addition to ensuring a more just society, closing these gaps could have a clear economic benefit.
Nassau County's Not Alone: Best Practices Around the Country to Embrace Opportunity and Limit Risk
For many local
governments, the CARES Act and ARPA funding are substantial
and could be transformational in their recovery efforts. Local leaders
will need to decide how to best use the funding while being consistent
with the federal requirements. Financial experts and think tanks around
the country are providing recommendations to ensure the long-term value
of investments and financial stability of its government using the
one-time infusion of federal resources. Think tanks, such as Citizens Budget Commission, National Association of Counties (NACo), and Fiscal Policy Institute, recommend the following general guiding principles:
The four blocks below detail these best practices and some localities that are putting them to use and achieving results.
1. Provide Accountability by Sharing Data on the Use and Impact of Federal Funds
City and County of Denver, Colorado
Denver established a public dashboard that would allow all program expenditures to be tracked and disseminated online. The dashboard demonstrated a breakdown of actual and committed spending by county departments (12).
Howard County, Maryland
Howard County created a CARES Act spending dashboard to track the actual and projected spending of federal funding in the interest of transparency (13).
2. Invest in Workforce Development:
Hillsborough County, Florida (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation: $256,847,065)
Hillsborough County allocated between $30-$60 million towards economic recovery programs and workforce training. The funding was administered in the form of grants to assist County residents in hardest-hit industries in retaining skills for in-demand industries and occupations, providing all necessary training materials and equipment, and funding paid work experience programs for displaced workers (14).
Ramsey County, Minnesota (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation: $96,026,770)
Ramsey County released contracting opportunities for non-profits to provide workforce-related services to people of color, people with disabilities, and veterans. Organizations focused on ending racial and socioeconomic disparities were encouraged to apply. Nearly 300 participants were known to have secured employment in the CARES Act Workforce Development funded programs. An additional nearly 300
participants increased the number of hours worked or wages paid (15).
3. Invest in Closing Equity Gaps:
Gwinnett County, Georgia (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation: $163,368,000)
Gwinnett County allocated a portion of the funds towards its COVID-19 Grant Funding Opportunity Program. The County encouraged nonprofit organizations to apply that had traditionally addressed critical needs within the community, such as emergency food assistance, house and emergency shelter, child care, transportation, and health care services. The County granted a total of $36 million in assistance to more than 233 nonprofit and faith-based agencies in the program's three rounds of application cycles (16).
Fairfax County, Virginia (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation:$387,176,021)
Fairfax County allocated up to $30 million towards its temporary Small Business and Non-Profit Relief Grant Program that helped small businesses and nonprofits impacted by COVID-19. Administered by the County Executive, the grant program sought to address gaps that may exist among complementary programs at the county, state, and federal level and provide targeted assistance to small, minority-owned businesses that were historically less likely to be approved for federal support (17). By the end of the program, the County reported that more than 72% of the grant recipients identified as organizations owned by women, minorities, and/or veterans (18).
4.
Support Temporary, Targeted Efforts that Address Hardships of the
Pandemic and Focus on Areas Not Supported by Federal and State Programs:
Honolulu County, Hawaii (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation:$387,176,021)
Honolulu County allocated a portion of the funds towards community services. This was administered through the form of grants that provided funding for shelters, homeless prevention, rapid re-housing, and other support services. Honolulu County also provided an additional $8 million to support efforts such as homeless prevention, food security, mobile COVID-19 testing, eviction prevention, acquisition for homeless clinics, drug treatment, and financial hardship relief (19).
Dallas County, Texas (Coronavirus Relief Fund allocation:$239,952,373)
Dallas County allocated funds to its Food Pantry Assistance program that provided one-time grants of up to $15,000 to county food banks, food pantries, soup kitchens, and community cupboards impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. The selected organizations were given reimbursements through the program at $2 per pound of food distributed from March to September 2020 (20).
Strike While the Iron is Hot
Trillions of dollars worth of Federal and State money has been infused
into local governments to combat the lingering economic effects of
COVID-19 shutdowns. It is incumbent upon governments to approach this
rare moment responsibly, with an eye toward strategic long-term
sustainability. Smart investments can make transformative progress and ensure that structural gaps are narrowed and closed
in our budgets and our communities.
The funding provided under ARPA provides a unique opportunity for state
and local governments to make strategic investments in long-lived
assets, enhance financial stability and cover
temporary operating shortfalls until economic conditions and operations
normalize.
In the meantime, if there are issues that you think the Policy and
Research Team should look into, or you have comments on our office’s
work, please feel free to reach out to us directly at ReportItReformIt@nassaucountyny.gov
Works Cited
1. "American Rescue Plan Spending: Recommended Guiding Principles." Coronavirus Response Resource Center, the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA), 2021, https://www.gfoa.org/american-rescue-plan-spending-guiding-principles.
2. "Curran Releases Proposed 2021-2024 Capital Improvement Plan." Nassau County County Executive News, Office of the Nassau County Executive, 16 Oct. 2020, https://www.nassaucountyny.gov/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=8540.
3. "Curran Calls on Washington for Infrastructure Stimulus for 12 Large Scale Improvement Projects." Nassau County County Executive News, Office of the Nassau County Executive, 14 Nov. 2020, https://www.nassaucountyny.gov/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=8684.
4. 4ward Planning. (2020). Land-Use Impacts Post Covid-19: Preparing the Comp Plan for Near- and Long-term Trends. Retrieved from https://secureservercdn.net/198.71.233.254/1da.948.myftpupload.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Land-Use-Impacts-Post-Covid-19-Long-Island-FInal.pdf?time=1602268588.
5. Regional Plan Association, Long Island Community Foundation, and Ford Foundation. (2018). Long Island Index 2018 Report. Retrieved from http://www.longislandindex.org/wpcontent/uploads/2018/04/COMMUNITIES_Index2018Report1.pdf.
6. "Long Island Index 2018 Report." Regional Plan Association, Long Island Community Foundation, and Ford Foundation, Long Island Index, 2018, http://www.longislandindex.org/wpcontent/uploads/2018/04/COMMUNITIES_Index2018Report1.pdf.
7. Lewis, Neal. "Long-Running Fight Over Downtown Development Finally Turns a Corner." Long Island Index, 26 Sep. 2016, http://www.longislandindex.org/2016/09/26/long-running-fight-over-downtown-development-finally-turns-a-corner/.
8. Eidler, Scott. "Laura Curran Proposes $375 Payments for 300,000 Nassau Property Owners." Newsday, 17 May 2021, https://www.newsday.com/long-island/politics/curran-nassau-375-cash-payments-1.50249256.
9. "The Cost of Child Care in New York." Economic Policy Institute, 2019, https://www.epi.org/child-care-costs-in-the-united-states/#/NY.
10. "Governor Cuomo Announces FY 2022 Budget Invests an Historic $5 Billion in Child Care, Fulfilling Many Recommendations Included in Child Care Availability Task Force Report." The Office of the Governor, the State of New York, 4 May 2021, https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-announces-fy-2022-budget-invests-historic-5-billion-child-care-fulfilling-many.
11. "County Executive Laura Curran Proposes Major Boost for Nassau’s Business Recovery." Nassau County County Executive News, Office of the Nassau County Executive, 19 May 2021, https://www.nassaucountyny.gov/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=9159.
12. "Financial Dashboards." The City and County of Denver Government, 2020-2021, https://www.denvergov.org/Government/COVID-19-Information/Public-Orders-Response/Response-Plans/Finance.
13. "Howard County CARES Act Funding for COVID-19 Relief." Office of Public Information for Howard County Government, 2020-2021, https://www.howardcountymd.gov/Departments/COVID-19-Coronavirus-Countywide-Updates/CARES-Act-Spending-Dashboard.
14. "CARES Act." CareerSource Tampa Bay, Florida, 2020, https://www.careersourcetampabay.com/cares-act/.
15. "CARES Workforce Development." The Ramsey County Government, Minnesota, Mar. 2021, https://www.ramseycounty.us/sites/default/files/Projects%20and%20Initiatives/Coronavirus/COVID-19/CARES%20Workforce%20Development%20Executive%20Summary.pdf.
16. "COVID-19 Nonprofit Funding Opportunity Awards." Grants, Gwinnett County Government, 2020, https://www.gwinnettcounty.com/web/gwinnett/departments/financialservices/grants#:~:text=COVID%2D19%20Nonprofit%20Funding%20Opportunity%20Awards&text=Through%20its%20Round%203%20application,nonprofit%20and%20faith%2Dbased%20agencies.
17. "COVID-19: Small Business Resources." COVID-19 Emergency: Information, Resources and Assistance for Businesses, Fairfax County Economic Development Authority, 2020-2021, https://www.fairfaxcountyeda.org/about-fceda/covid-19-response/covid-19-small-business-resources/.
18. Waseem, Fatimah. "Fairfax County RISE Program Awards Over $52 Million to Small Businesses." RestonNow, 14 Dec. 2020, https://www.restonnow.com/2020/12/14/fairfax-county-rise-program-awards-over-52-million-to-small-businesses/.
19. "Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act)." Economic Assistance and Revitalization Committee, City and County of Honolulu, 13 May 2020, https://honolulu.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=3&clip_id=1313&meta_id=138549.
20. "Dallas County Food Pantry Assistance Program." The County of Dallas, State of Texas, 4 Aug. 2020, https://www.dallascounty.org/cares-act/food-pantry-en.php#:~:text=If%20assistance%20is%20needed%2C%20please,organization%20providing%20food%20pantry%20services.